Vol. 98 (2026)
Articles

Un premier projet d’assurance maladie au Québec: la commission Lessard entre autonomie provinciale et justice sociale (1936–1943)

Cory Verbauwhede
Université du Québec à Montréal
Cover of Labour/Le Travail, Volume 98

Published 2026-11-17

Keywords

  • Lessard Commission,
  • public assistance,
  • Public Charities Act,
  • hospitals,
  • health insurance,
  • Québec labour movement,
  • provincial autonomy,
  • subsidiarity,
  • social state,
  • welfare state,
  • social policies
  • ...More
    Less

How to Cite

Verbauwhede, C. (2026). Un premier projet d’assurance maladie au Québec: la commission Lessard entre autonomie provinciale et justice sociale (1936–1943). Labour Le Travail, 98, 257–295. https://doi.org/10.52975/llt.2026v98.011

Abstract

This article examines the origins and work of the Provincial Commission of Inquiry on Hospitals, a pivotal moment in the evolution of social policy in Quebec. Drawing on previously untapped archival sources, it demonstrates how labour demands and mounting financial pressures on hospitals exposed the limitations of a public assistance model based on charity and family responsibility. The Lessard Commission marked the culmination of a process that began in the mid-1930s, amid the revival of the Liberal Party under Adélard Godbout. The inquiry gradually shifted the debate from hospital funding toward a broader conception of public responsibility. While Ottawa was considering new social initiatives, the Commission recommended the implementation of a compulsory provincial health insurance plan. The project was ultimately abandoned after the Union Nationale’s narrow election victory in 1944, in the name of resisting federal interference. This abandonment illustrates the political ambivalence of provincial autonomy, mobilized in turn as a vehicle for reform or as a tool of obstruction. This episode reveals an early, abortive attempt to establish a Quebec welfare state based on citizenship rather than on the figure of the pauper.